The TRAVELER'S JOURNAL, April thirtieth, correcting first class misconceptions.

When you're seated in first class on an airplane, you expect the very best service on that flight. But travelers checking into a similarly rated hotel are often underwhelmed by what they find. Truth is with hotels first class isn't the best. In fact, it's decidedly midrange.

The Official Hotel Guide is both the most commonly used standard for accommodations and the only rating system consistent around the world. The OHG uses three major categories to rate hotels, deluxe, first class and tourist. Each category also has a superior and moderate level, sort of a plus and minus gradient. A tenth category, Limited-Service First Class is given to hotels with good guest rooms but little in the way of meeting space or ballrooms.

The OHG and various other hotel rating systems can be good yardsticks by which to adjust your expectations, but none should be taken as absolute guarantees. Standardized systems work strictly by the numbers, measuring tangibles such as the size and number of guest rooms and public spaces. They have a harder time calculating more subtle factors, such as ambiance and personal service, which can make a big difference in a stay. On the other hand, why pay premium prices for a hotel with a great conference center you'll never use?

When evaluating accommodations in an unfamiliar city, the best option is a personal recommendation from a knowledgeable source. That failing try a good guidebook, whether in print or online, one with evaluations based on recent, onsite inspections. And don't arrive expecting superior deluxe if you're only paying for first class.

Back to May 2003 Main

Look through the list of fascinating places and off-beat features we’ve covered. Search text versions of past episodes and articles in our archives.